Episode Transcript
[00:00:00] Speaker A: Most firm owners I talk to can tell me their cost per lead down to the dollar, sometimes even the cents. Now, ask them what happens to those leads, and they don't usually have such a ready answer, and especially not when you're asking them what happens to the leads they turn down. Now, if you're in the industry, you've heard of Gary Falkowitz. He ran intake as managing attorney at Parker waichman. He wrote the book on intake and he has been preaching the gospel of strong intake conversion for years now. He, he built a company capture now doing AI intake before anyone was in the AI space. And he runs the intake playbook where he has been inside hundreds of firms. Gary, I've wanted to talk to you on the podcast for a long time. Welcome to the Relay.
[00:00:45] Speaker B: Gabriel, so good to talk to you. The feeling is mutual. Thanks for that intro. This is, this is fun for me, so thanks for having me.
[00:00:51] Speaker A: Fantastic. Glad to have you here. I want to start off just with a little bit of your own background. For those who are listening, who are new to you. I gave the overview. What would you add to that? And how in the same hill did you end up as the intake guy? That's a pretty big deal.
[00:01:07] Speaker B: First of all, thank you for that title. Yeah. If you told me when I was in law school that somehow I would focus my career on intake, I'd have no idea what you were talking about. Let's start there. Right? But for me, I'll fast forward through becoming an assistant district attorney in Brooklyn, New York, where the accent. I'm born and raised in Brooklyn, so that'll come out pretty, pretty, pretty quickly. And obviously. And then I became a medical malpractice defense attorney for a year. Knew that wasn't for me. Jumped over to the good side, the personal injury side, where you got to represent folks who were injured by no fault of their own. Through no fault of their own. And I think it was there that Parker Wakeman's office where very quickly I always found myself to be someone who understood other people well. And I was willing to put in the time to prioritize and strengthen relationships.
And it was something I did just as a human being having nothing to do with a business.
And when I got the Parker Wakeman and I saw this law firm, I knew very little about the personal injury industry other than the negative connotation of ambulance chasers. So I was definitely hesitant at the outset.
And when I got there and I saw all these different departments, from intake to settlements to pre lit to lit to There was a nursing team and there was a reception team. And it's one for another, first of all, and I'll always give kudos, too, and a big thank you to Jared Parker and that firm, because it's there where my eyes opened up to this. This idea that I think many law firms still are having a hard time understanding, which is running a personal injury law firm is running a business.
And you got to stop there because they're two completely different things, right? Being a lawyer and being a business owner, they require a different thought process. They require. Require different goals.
And when I got to the firm and it hit me that this was a business, the light bulb went off in my head about, how do you make this a very successful. He was doing great on his baseball when he created years before I got there. But I started thinking, hey, what can I do? I'm really interested in the front end side of this business. What can I do to further that goal? I remember sitting down with him within three to four weeks of being hired and saying, jerry, thanks so much for this opportunity. And I had this whole printed document that I memorized because I drafted it because I was going to make such a courageous ask. And I said to him, if I could ever be involved in the front end side of the business, I would love to do that. He looked at me and said, hey, I appreciate you sharing that with me. Now please go back to your office and be the lawyer I paid you to be. And that's fine. But I got inside of his head and I continued to do so. In about two years, I became the managing attorney of the intake department at the firm. And I got to tell you, it just. It hit me like a ton of bricks. And what hit me was that law firms were leaving way too much money on the table due to what was or what was not happening at intake. And then I just. I dove in, man. I. Whether it's the book or the consulting or my masterclass or the call center or the AI, like, I just didn't slow down, and I'm not slowing down. This is where I think there's really tremendous opportunities for law firms to win that they're not. They're not buying into yet.
[00:04:26] Speaker A: Which I would say is shocking, given that you've been talking about this for years. It is a key part of the industry talk, right? You're not the only guy who's out there saying, hey, law firms need to do better intake, and here's how to do it. And you have a loud voice in it. But Like, I'm curious, what do you think is the blocker here? Is it that most law firms still are run by guys who view themselves as lawyers? And, and also, do you think since you started your career here that it has changed or do you think that you're still. We're still basically in a place where intake isn't viewed as a key part of the business. Because I have my thoughts, but I'd like to hear yours first.
[00:05:05] Speaker B: So I'm gonna, I'm gonna take the second question first. Do I think that maybe, and I'll ask it a little differently, do I think that maybe I had, I've had any impact on this, on the intake in our industry, whether people are changing. Every conference I go to now, and I'm on stage a lot, every conference I go to now, there's someone who stops me and says, I just need to tell you whether it was this line that you said at your last conference or this line in your book or this thing you had in your podcast, it helped me make either this much money or sign this big case or make this big change that had a huge impact on our firm. So, absolutely, I, as well as everyone else that is. And you. That is pushing a prioritize intake. It's working. Is absolutely working. I see it, I feel it. My consulting clients are proving it to me. It's. And I'm a big fan of seeing the fruit of your labor. Right. I don't. I'm not patient enough to take a job that would require 10 years before I saw the fruit of the labor. I can't do it. I got to constantly see the fruit of the labor. I like to see that, the rewards and what I'm doing. And also the proof of concept is working because otherwise you're just going by, by guessing. Now go back to your first question, which is what's the blocker?
There are a few things that stand out here. Number one, you're trying to convince people who are already successful to make changes to something in their process that they never wanted to make changes to. And that is very uncomfortable. And why would they do that if they're already successful? That's a major blocker for somebody to tell a winner that they have to change the way they play the game, to tell Steph Curry, hey, maybe you shouldn't be shooting threes. What do you do? What do you mean? I'm the best three point shooter to ever play the game. How can you share that with me? Sometimes there are attorneys and law firms that do have that. That feeling of I'm crushing it. What do you mean? I'm doing something wrong? I don't believe it. I don't buy it. So I'm not doing it. That's a big blocker. That. Whether it's the. The arrogance, if you want to call it, or some other words come to mind, but that's a blocker. Another blocker is
[00:07:12] Speaker A: I want to push. I want to drill down into that one a little bit, because, yeah, that. That's. In some ways, that's a legitimate response. Listen, Gary, like, I'm doing fine. Like, why would I change? I got a house, I got another house. I got another house. I got it. You know, what's. What is the pain there? And is that the same kind of, hey, things are working well for me top to bottom? Or is there. Are there different types of success where smaller firms have it in some ways and larger firms have it in other ways?
[00:07:37] Speaker B: They have different. Right. The size of the law firm you're in could certainly dictate where the blockers are, where the issues are. But let me answer your question, which is how do I get over that hump potentially? Or what do I tell someone who feels that way? And I think what's really important is to remind them what their goals are.
Your goal with this firm is to help as many people as possible and to make as much money as possible, not to help some people and to make some money. Your goal is to maximize the return on your investment in the firm.
Everything you're doing, whether it's the staff you're paying, whether it's the marketing you're investing in, whether it's the CRM or the technology or the AI, everything you're doing, really, the goal is to maximize the return on what you're doing. And I think that's really the big. The distinction between what they're thinking and now and what they could be thinking. So when you ask them straight up and you say, hey, so I know you crushed the last year, probably your best year yet, but do you know how many leads that you wanted and lost?
And they look, you go, do you mean of all the leads that you wanted, the ones that you wanted to sign, they qualified?
How many did you end up losing, maybe to another competitor or just someone that you stopped communicating with?
I signed all the cases I want is usually what you hear.
And then when you let them, if they let you open up their books and they're. I say their book, but their crf, their files, and they start to see the Mistakes.
And they start to see the cracks.
That's the conversation where. And I've had this a hundred times where the attorney goes, scratch their head. And they go, how long were we doing that for?
How many cases did we lose? Because we did that, because we made that decision, because that was the process.
And at that point, they move away from, oh, I've been doing great. I have the houses, the cars, the yachts.
And they move more to, oh, my God, how much should I leave at the table? How much money fell through the cracks? How many potential clients that would have referred more business to me did I push away because of this one process over here? And I think that's where you got to get to. I've had law firms say to me, gary, and it's my favorite line, I'm bringing you in.
I don't think anything's wrong, but I'm bringing you in just so you can tell me nothing's wrong.
I love that line because it means to me a couple things. One, it shows some modesty from the law firm. Are they confident? Sure. But they're not certain.
And they want an objective eye to come in and confirm it for them, to reassure them that they're doing great, because they've been quote, guessing and improvising this whole way through, and they don't see any cracks. They're not. They don't have the. The glasses that I have. And then when I'll come in and within an hour or two, like, oh, man, I'm so glad you're here. I didn't know that, or, let's start making that change. How do we fix that immediately? And that's, to me, that's the fruit of the labor. When you put in the 15 or 20 years that I've put in, and then you're able to share that with your community, and then your community is able to help more people or build a better business, it makes you feel really good.
[00:10:43] Speaker A: So one thing that I think is really interesting is that you launched Capture now, really not even before, like, voice AI was a thing. You launched it before, like, people were doing AI. And I was at the. The CRISP Conference and the Ben Stadium, where you got up on stage and you announced everybody and all that, and it was ballsy. First of all, we've seen, obviously, massive improvements since then, right? Absolutely phenomenal.
I still think that the best version of intake, the most effective version, is not AI driven. You have an AI product. And also you are an advocate for doing a doing intake such that you don't let anything fall through the cracks.
What's your current position on where those two things come together? Right. Because there's this shifting line. Right. Like early days, AI is like, hey, let's create a catcher's myth that, like, if something was going to just completely fall through the cracks, better that than nothing.
There's some people out there that are saying, yo, intake is almost there. Our AI is almost there.
It's going to revolutionize intake. We're never going to have human beings again. We're going to fire all of call center people. It's going to be amazing. Humans don't want to talk to humans anyway. Where are we? And you've had a firsthand seat for a while. How far has that line come since the launch? And are we ever going to fire the entire human call center?
[00:11:59] Speaker B: Yeah, this one is a. This one's a fun one for me. And not enough people ask it. Right. It's the right question to ask Gary Falcoitz. Hey, Gary, you're pushing me. Intake, intake. And then you're creating AI for intake. What are you doing, man? Pick a side.
That's what you might be thinking. And the reality is this. I love intake staff. They're my favorite people. I think that part of me, I think that they hold so much more power than most law firm owners and most attorneys can. Can even fathom. They. They hold more power than what the attorneys do, in my opinion. But they are only good at the moment that they're available.
And there's this big thing, actually, we recently presented this at a conference. For the longest time, law firms thought they had to choose between speed and quality, speed and quality. Do I get so many people hire so many people around the clock that I am the first person to pick up and to make an outbound call to a web lead. And I will never miss a call.
Right. That's extremely expensive. No one chooses that option. Or do I try to focus on getting quality staff and try to make sure hopefully, that the trade offs aren't too much, not leaving too much money on the table. And the quality staff, during the hours I hire them are able to handle the calls that come in and they can make the calls back. And everybody chose that option.
Now, five years ago, 10 years ago, that was the right option to choose because those are the only two options we could choose from. No one's going to just take a few million dollars and hire people around the clock, knowing that 80% of their time is going to be wasted doing nothing.
On top of that, the Staff get so bombarded with their responsibilities that they're having a really hard time following the appropriate cadence and the responsibilities they have internally that they're leaving money inadvertently on the table. So how do you do that? How do you fix that? How do you say, gary, you love the people, but you also love AI? But where's the medium? Where's the happy medium? Here's where the happy medium is. And this is why we created the product. So I had a call center, right? It was called Intake Conversion Experts, who was ultimately acquired. We signed over 200,000 cases for law firms nationwide. But I did the hiring, I did the, the interviewing, I did the managing of these staff being in the room that they were. And unfortunately we couldn't meet the standards every single day, every minute of every day that I wanted to meet. So when we, the business was taken over, my business partner and I, Chris o', Brien, and I said, what's next? What is next in our industry at the front end of the business? And it was right before AI and we said, you know what, we've got to guarantee an immediate response. We got to guarantee an immediate response. Too many people are hanging up after four, five, six rings. Too many people aren't. And then no one's getting in touch with them. You don't know how much you're leaving on the table in an industry where there are tremendous margins. And that's why we created Capture. Now, now, what do I think? What do I think the happy medium is? I think you make sure that AI answers and makes outbound calls to web leads immediately. I think immediacy with technology is the win. Once you have the immediacy and maybe you're able to even qualify the lead, then you hand it over to your rock stars. Then you hand it over to your intake staff who close out those cases, get them signed, potentially escalated to an attorney if you have to. But why waste money on folks to dial and leave voicemails or potentially not not use the appropriate follow up case that they're supposed to use? That's a gamble. So we want to remove the gamble and put in some guarantees. And when the technology allows you to implement guarantees in the front end of the business, you do it. You don't walk away from it. You don't go, oh, I just want to walk. Have my people pick up. Your people might not be available. And that's eight rings. Then it goes to your call center. That might be another 8 rings. Who here has stayed on the phone for 16 rings? I have it. I Would say the phone for eight rings and at all in any business in years.
So within an environment that has a tremendous number of options and that's extremely competitive, if you are not fast, if you are not first, you're leaving money on the table. And I think that's where we brought the AI into the plan, into intake. And it's just paying off a dividend, some believe.
[00:15:52] Speaker A: And how much further have you been able to bring it into intake over the past three years? Is it largely what it was at the outset, but the workflows are stronger or do you have in, do you have more voice AI embedded in those flows? Is it like how much is that human still? The key part of. Because what I'm seeing now across the industry is you have companies that are doing more of the AI coaching and literally here's the window and it's listening and transcribing and then giving you real time coaching. If you're an intake agent and then you've got other ones that are like, hey, it'll handle a 10 minute call autonomously for someone and then it'll hand it over to somebody else. Those are, both of those are relatively new, like last two years that those have really come into fruition. Which of those paths are you more interested in? Which of them have you pulled into your system?
[00:16:41] Speaker B: Yeah, I think when we think about our product we're really thinking about and thankfully with all the experience I've had and all the relationships that I've created, I get a better sense on this than maybe some other companies. We're really thinking about the majority of the industry. We not thinking about the onesie2z demands or requests. And for example, how many law firms are using an AI to coach their intake staff Right now? It's very few within the industry. We wanted to make sure that if you want to use the 8020 rule, we wanted to have a product that was going to satisfy what 80% of the law firms needed. And are we using the most updated technology? Absolutely. Are we able to. Whether it's the integration, whether it's a follow up cadence, whether it's trying to get a case signed, we're doing all of those things. But I think to make it easier for law firms, we're letting them determine, hey, what do you need here? What do you want here? Do you want every. Do you want us to get someone on the phone and want transfer to an available agent every time immediately after someone's on the phone or do you want us to qualify using your qualification criteria? Or do you want us to sign it and then refer out and send it out to your law firm or some other law firm? So I think it's very customizable, but it's also very basic in its use. It's most. Here's what I'll say and I'd love to get your thoughts as well.
I would say, obviously we're in an AI boom right now, right? It's November 2026, AI quote taking over.
I would argue that at intake, AI is still only being used in less than 5% of the law firms.
I don't think it's, I don't think it's a large number right now. I think it's still.
[00:18:11] Speaker A: When you say being used, you mean for full conversion flows or at all? Like
[00:18:16] Speaker B: some
[00:18:17] Speaker A: non human talks to somebody?
[00:18:19] Speaker B: I'm talking about in terms of communication with the caller. Communication with the caller inbound or outbound, not the AI processes behind intake, not critiquing things of that nature. I'm talking about a voice bot AI speaking with a claimant, a potential claimant. You're still think you're still looking at a tiny minority of our industry that's using.
[00:18:42] Speaker A: I agree. I think it's. I think it's less than 5%. I don't think it, I don't think it should be higher. My take is that humans are the best possible pathway now and probably will be at least for another couple years. AI is moving really quickly. But that is the best way to convert right now, the way I like an intake to.
[00:19:05] Speaker B: Let me challenge you for a moment. Right. I agree that humans will convert better than AI right now, Absolutely.
But will humans pick up the phone faster? No, I'm talking about a consistent basis. On a predictable basis, will the human being pick up the phone? A human being who has other responsibilities, who has limited time, who is prioritizing what my next responsibility or activity should be, will that person who's also potentially texting with their spouse or their kids or looking to find a doctor's appointment online, whatever it is, all important things. Is that human being going to pick up the call that's ringing at their desk faster than AI Answer is no. And I'm talking about on a consistent and predictable basis, will a human being call back a web lead? Right. An intake team of human beings whose jobs are 20, 30, 40 items long and a web lead comes in, the guarantee that a human being is going to call that webly back in 10 seconds.
It's not guaranteed. It's still a gamble.
[00:20:08] Speaker A: No no, that's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about the actual close. You're on a call, you have a human being who's been injured. That person wants to talk to a human being. It's if, dude, if you called 911 and the AI said, what is your emergency?
How comfortable would you feel that you'd be? Like, this is insane.
[00:20:24] Speaker B: I think you and I say that, and I think we, we say, yeah, ideally that person wants to talk to human being.
And then I look at how many cases we've been able to convert through an AI conversation and it's maybe I was mistaken. Maybe only maybe we have to figure out which claimants really want to talk. Maybe it's a high value claimant. Maybe it's someone who's had a bad experience with AI. Maybe it's someone that had a really bad experience with a human and decided, I don't want to do that anymore. This AI is going fast, direct, not judging me, not making any, coming to any conclusions. So it's really hard right now. It's really hard right now to say what the target audience is preferring because I think what I keep coming back to is have it all.
I don't want AI to replace people at intake. I love, I've listened to tens of thousands of phone calls and I love when there's a, when there's a connection made. And I can tell by minute one, 1 minute and 14 seconds that this is going to end up in a signed case. Just because the intake specialist said, oh my God, my brother's name is Jonathan too. And all of a sudden, I know you, Jonathan, and there's a connection. Boom. I know they're going to sign the case. Doesn't matter what said the rest of that call. I love that. But I also see it the other way. So it's, I think what we have to do as a business owner in society is not to give a caller or potential customer one way to win.
Right. We want to be able to, if 10 customers walk into our store, we want to be able to satisfy all 10 customers regardless of how they want, what they want. And at a law firm, we've got to be able to offer that. We can't just say we only mail out our packets. It doesn't work that way. Right. It just doesn't work that way. So I think as a business owner, we better have options available so that whoever calls up, we're meeting their demands.
[00:22:10] Speaker A: Yeah, but there's also a design component where you're Walking them through, through a journey. Right. And as AI gets better, it will continue to encroach on the ability of what people can do. Because AI is going to win and machines are going to win on consistency. Like they're going to win on speed. Like you said, 100% right? Inbound and outbound speed they can pick up forever. They're infinitely scalable, I'm willing to say, like it's a shrinking island that is just what people can do. Can AI say my brother's name is Jonathan? Yes. Is that a lie? Yes. The brother's name could always be Jonathan, Mark, Ed, whatever. To build that level of empathy.
There's disclosure pieces now that have to be thought through around, like disclosing that it's AI. But I think the question that I'm coming at is how much does that island shrink and how much are you putting people into harnesses that are agentic and are able to move them through the process in ways that are more consistent? Because I think that's what's really interesting is 3 years ago you couldn't go real time, transcribe pop contextual notes and a coach live on a call for a human being. People should be performing better now than they were. Like, are you seeing that side where you're getting more consistency out of the people, better leverage from the human beings who are sitting in those seats? Because the technology is changing dramatically.
[00:23:29] Speaker B: I think you let the, you let the experience teach you what is needed and wanted.
Do I. Is AI doing more and are people doing less?
Yes, of course. And that's going to continue to happen. I think that there are you asked whether am I seeing a difference in the people, productivity or work product based upon what AI is doing in terms of helping them understand what's working and what's not working, how they can improve.
I've seen it both ways. I've seen people that are amazing, they're wonderful. And if somehow AI takes over intake, they need to do something else in my firm because they're just unbelievable at creating a relationship with folks. But I will say this.
If we're gonna to put a bow on the AI, I would say this.
I would say that in this day and age, you cannot just cruise as a human being in the work office.
You've got to be great.
And if you're great, you're going to be very valuable at the front, at least for the next five years, for sure. You're going to be very valuable. If you're just cruising and you're just checking the boxes and you're not looking to create a relationship. And you're calling when you can call, and you follow up when you can follow up, and you tell someone who'll call you back, because I have to go talk to an attorney. I'm not sure if it's the case we can handle any of those things. If that's you, AI is going to beat you, that you have no shot, you can't win.
But if you and I are talking about. The rock stars are always going to have value in a firm, especially the next few years. The rock stars are the closers. The rock stars are the ones that know how to say what the claimant should expect post retention, that know how to manage expectations about what the litigation looks like, that know how to describe who the legal team is and what they're like, and know how to say that if my own brother or sister. Yeah. Needed a lawyer, this is who you want to work with. The rock stars know that the AI is learning, but they're. We all see it. The AI is still limited to what your prompt and questions are. Right. Sure. It can fix itself. When you say, I didn't want that. I wanted something else. But at the moment, your rock stars are the most valuable people at intake. And the folks that are just cruising, that are just making it, coming to work and getting through the day, they're going to. They're going to be the first ones out. Right? AI just is so much better than that.
[00:25:57] Speaker A: Yeah. Yeah. I'm. I'm very much in the camp right now on, on intake and these really human elements. Right. It applies to litigation. It's doing two things at the same time. One, it's raising the floor. It just is continually bringing the floor up from where it was five years ago. There was no AI. Floor is here now. The other thing it's doing is it's making people better. Your best litigators now have access to AI. They can go through a thousand documents in five seconds in the courtroom while the defense is making their argument. You're in your AI system looking for rebuttals, looking for things you haven't seen before. That's crazy. That's also true. That's across every single part of the law firm. Now, I don't necessarily think if you're a rocks, I think if you're a rock star, you shouldn't be afraid, because I. I don't think that's going away, but I think that the harness is going to get more powerful and there's some crazy future world where maybe you're on literally five calls at the same time with an AI that's using your voice and you're coaching the AI on how to close five different callers. There's some crazy stuff that's going to happen over the next few years. And but to your point, the fundamentals don't change, right? The numbers don't change. You're one closing the cases you want doesn't change. And the need for human empathy because ultimately we're in very human business. And so this has been great. Gary. I. We ended up a little bit far afield from what I wanted to talk about. That is. That is fine. I actually like episodes like that better. We are, as we close. Any. Any final thoughts on intake, on what you're seeing happening across the industry?
[00:27:25] Speaker B: You know, I'll just say this. So I have the industry's largest intake masterclass and I bring that up not from a sales pitch, more from like what we were just talking about. I love a law firm that prioritizes intake. If you're going to have people picking up the phones, making phone calls, talking to claimants, they have to be trained really well. They have to understand what's in there, what the claimant's mentality is and what the law firm's expectations are. So we talk about that a lot in my masterclass. If I had to give you a closing line here for the podcast. And by the way, awesome. This is fun to talk about. This is not going away. This is only scratching the surface. I would say that law firms, if you're watching this and you got this far and you're spending money generating leads for your firm and you're not focused, hyper focused, or have someone hyper focused on what's going on with every lead and what your team is saying and why you're leaving money on the table and why claimants are choosing your competitors, if you're not looking into it in a detailed basis, you're likely leaving a lot of money on the table. And my imploration door, I implore you to please spend some time, figure it out, get involved, learn what it takes to convert a qualified claim into a signed case. Because at the end of the day, 30 years ago, maybe you were the only big law firm in town and you could tell somebody, hey, let me think about it and get back to you. You can no longer do that. It is such a competitive industry and the more you prioritize a dig, the less you'll lose cases. So that was Gabriel. Thanks so much for your time. Today is great.
[00:28:49] Speaker A: Thanks, Gary. Really appreciate it. No excuses. I agree with that wholeheartedly. Thanks for being on the show.
[00:28:54] Speaker B: My pleasure.